GamesBeat Next is a premier event connecting the next generation of video game leaders. Join us on October 28th and 29th in San Francisco! Don’t miss our buy one, get one free pass offer, ending on August 16th. Register here.
Nintendo and The Pokémon Company have filed a lawsuit against Palworld maker Pocket Pair for patent infringement today, as reported by Nintendo.
The lawsuit comes as no surprise considering the popularity of Palworld, which racked up over 25 million downloads earlier this year, often referred to as “Pokémon with Guns.”
Nintendo stated that the lawsuit aims to obtain an injunction against the infringement and seek compensation for damages, citing that Palworld, a game developed and released by the defendant, violates multiple patent rights.
Nintendo is committed to taking necessary actions against any violations of its intellectual property rights, including safeguarding the Nintendo brand, which it has diligently built over the years. We have reached out to Pocket Pair for a comment.
Join us for GamesBeat Next!
GamesBeat Next is the ultimate hub for the next generation of video game leaders. Join us on October 28th and 29th in San Francisco to network and learn from industry experts. Take advantage of our buy one, get one free pass offer, valid until August 16th. Register here to secure your spot!
While the specifics of the lawsuit are not yet available, it raises an important legal question about the fine line between inspiration and infringement when creating a game. While there are numerous real-time strategy games in the market, no single company holds a patent on RPG games. However, directly copying artwork and other elements from someone else’s RPG game is not permitted. I recently led a panel on this topic at Devcom in Germany, focusing on copyright and AI.
More information is needed to provide a comprehensive analysis, but it’s challenging to see how Palworld, a distinct game from Pokémon, could potentially infringe on patents (not copyrights). Initially, it seems like Nintendo may be overreaching. https://t.co/3L2D5EZ7hh
— Richard Hoeg (@HoegLaw) September 18, 2024
While the artwork for some Palworld characters bears resemblance to Pokémon characters, the gameplay differs significantly as Pokémon is not a violent shooter or survival game. The question arises as to how much similarity in art would constitute infringement in the eyes of the court. This will likely be clarified in the proceedings.
Contrary to popular belief, The Pokémon Company previously succeeded in a copyright infringement case, but this current lawsuit pertains to patent infringement.
GB Daily
Stay up-to-date with the latest news delivered to your inbox daily
Thank you for subscribing. Explore more VB newsletters here.
An error occurred.
**FAQs**
**Q:** How does Nintendo plan to address the alleged patent infringement by Pocket Pair?
**A:** Nintendo intends to seek an injunction against the infringement and pursue compensation for damages.
**Q:** What key legal points will be addressed in this lawsuit between Nintendo and Pocket Pair?
**A:** The lawsuit will explore the boundaries between inspiration and infringement in game development, particularly in relation to patent rights.
**Q:** What distinguishes Palworld from Pokémon, despite the similarities in character artwork?
**A:** While there may be visual resemblances, Palworld offers a different gameplay experience compared to the non-violent nature of Pokémon.
**Q:** How long did it take for Nintendo and The Pokémon Company to file this lawsuit against Pocket Pair?
**A:** The timing of the lawsuit is noteworthy considering the significant downloads of Palworld earlier this year, garnering attention as a “Pokémon with Guns” game.
Credit: venturebeat.com
