Overpolicing of Narratives

House of the Dragon’s King Consort Matt Smith, known for his role as Daemon Targaryen in the HBO fantasy series, has sparked controversy with his stance on trigger warnings: “Isn’t being shocked, surprised, stirred the point?”

Challenging Trigger Warnings

In a recent interview with The Times, Smith expressed his concern about the prevalence of trigger warnings in modern media. He questioned whether preemptively alerting audiences to potentially upsetting content diminishes the impact of storytelling, stating, “It’s okay to feel uncomfortable or provoked while looking at a painting or watching a play, but I worry everything’s being dialed and dumbed down.”

The Debate Over Trigger Warnings

Trigger warnings, often displayed before TV episodes or films, inform viewers about the graphic nature of the content to follow, such as violence and sexuality. However, some critics view the use of trigger warnings as a form of censorship and believe it hinders the authentic viewing experience.

Throughout his career, Smith has portrayed complex and morally ambiguous characters, from his role as Daemon Targaryen to Prince Philip in The Crown and Charles Manson in Charlie Says. When asked about his attraction to such characters, he emphasized the importance of telling challenging stories in today’s society.

Smith criticized the trend of excessive caution in storytelling, stating, “Too much policing of stories and being afraid to bring them out because a climate is a certain way is a shame.” He expressed reservations about the use of trigger warnings in media.

Controversies Surrounding Media Content

House of the Dragon has faced backlash for its lack of warnings, particularly before a violent birthing scene in a season 1 episode. Despite having a TV-MA rating, indicating content unsuitable for children under 17, the show continues to be scrutinized for its explicit content.

Sign up for Entertainment Weekly’s free daily newsletter to stay updated on the latest TV news and interviews with your favorite stars.

Reflecting on his own exposure to mature content at a young age, Smith recalled watching provocative films that left a lasting impact on him. He emphasized the lasting effects of such experiences on his perception of storytelling.

Photo: Adrian Rogers/BBC

Streaming platforms like Netflix have taken steps to include trigger warnings in shows like The Politician and Stranger Things, addressing sensitive topics such as mental health and gun violence. These warnings aim to provide viewers with additional context before engaging with potentially distressing content.

The debate over trigger warnings extends to their impact on mental health, with organizations cautioning against the risk of sensationalized content contributing to suicidal thoughts in vulnerable individuals.

Cultural Debates and Representation in Media

Smith criticized the backlash against diverse casting decisions in popular shows like Doctor Who, highlighting the absurdity of objections to non-traditional portrayals of iconic characters. He emphasized the importance of embracing inclusivity and creativity in storytelling.

Subscribe to Entertainment Weekly’s newsletter for the latest updates on your favorite TV shows and stars.

As a former Doctor on Doctor Who, Smith reflected on his tenure and the evolution of the show’s casting choices, welcoming the diversity and innovation brought by subsequent actors in the role.

Representatives for Smith declined to comment on his remarks.

FAQs

What are trigger warnings, and why are they controversial?

Trigger warnings are disclaimers shown before media content to alert viewers to potentially distressing or graphic material. However, some critics argue that these warnings inhibit storytelling and dilute the impact of the content.

How do trigger warnings impact mental health?

Some organizations warn that exposure to sensitive or explicit content, even with trigger warnings, can have negative effects on individuals struggling with mental health conditions. It could potentially increase the risk of harmful behaviors like suicidal ideation.

Credit: ew.com